'Are You The One?': Shelby Breaks Nathan's Heart

Empty Lighthouse is a reader-supported site. This article may contain affiliate links to Amazon and other sites. We earn a commission on purchases made through these links.

Shelby let Nathan down super hard on the new episode of 'Are You The One?'

Last week, Shelby chose to lock it in with Dario, needing to get some space from Nathan and see new people, and Nathan was not taking the hint.

Nathan aggressively approached Shelby, telling her that he wants to be with her now and when the show is all over, but Shelby thinks he's coming on way too strong.

She doesn't know if Nathan is the one, and wants to take the time to see other people without Nathan smothering her.

"I want to take time to work this out. I want to be the one you want," Nathan pleaded with Shelby as he cornered her in the house. And then it was Dario to the rescue!

Dario came to Shelby's side, and Nathan basically threw a tantrum and started crying. "Just send me home!" he yelled. "None of this perfect match bullsh*t is worth this!" He was totally distraught.

"That was one of the coolest things he's ever done for me. It was really attractive to me," Shelby told the house about Dario. Do we detect a spark between the two?

"I hate her. I hate her more than life right now," Nathan later told Tyler. Why? "Because she took my heart and ripped it in half!" The melodrama increases.