'Catfish' MTV: 'Tyreme & Tomorrow' Recap, Who is Tomorrow?
Empty Lighthouse is a reader-supported site. This article may contain affiliate links to Amazon and other sites. We earn a commission on purchases made through these links.
Once again MTV's Catfish hands Nev Schulman and Max Joseph a seemingly impossible mission in season five. Tyreme reaches out to the guys to see if Tomorrow has been catfishing him.
Tyreme (Facebook) is a 27-year-old father of two from Virginia. Tyreme has had his life change since meeting Tomorrow online. He is ready to leave everything he knows to be with her but there doesn't seem to be the same type of love being reciprocated on her end. Tomorrow refuses to video chat because her camera is always broken.
However, he has spoken to her family on multiple occasions. Tyreme (Instagram) is looking for answers and he is seeking help from Joseph and Schulman in his email.
The guys decide to give Tyreme a call and after a little chat they agree to help him with his Catfish problem.
Upon meeting up with Tyreme (Twitter) he tells a story of being diabetic and how the conversation between he and Tomorrow began. Tyreme says he made a post about making pancakes on Facebook and Tomorrow liked it.
So, Tyreme messaged her and went on from there.
Tyreme found out that Tomorrow was also diabetic and Joseph funnily pointed out that two diabetics bonded over talk of pancakes.
He says what really made him fall in love with Tomorrow was her support when his cousin and his grandmother passed away just within a week of each other.
Tyreme reveals that Tomorrow had a friend Letrease but things went downhill when Tomorrow and Tyreme broke up. Tomorrow slept with Letrease's child's father.
She got pregnant and had a miscarriage but Tyreme still wanted to be a part of her life.
Tyreme seems convinced that Tomorrow is who she says she is. The guys think that Tyreme has a wakeup call coming and that they could be dealing with an entire family catfishing one person.
Tyreme's grandmother died of cancer and his cousin died of diabetes. He had never dealt with loss like that and Tomorrow was there for him. Tyreme says that she was the first person he called when the tragedies struck and he cried on the phone with her.
After hearing his story and getting a little more details on the relationship. Schulman and Joseph went off to do some investigating on their own to see what they could com up with.
The guys start by searching the images and after striking out multiple times they get a hit on a profile for an Aryssa, from Kansas City, Missouri. They check out some more photos and realize that it is the girl that is in the photos Tyreme has seen. They immediately begin to think the worst.
They then look up Aryssa on Facebook and after putting everything together, they send a message to Aryssa.
The message was sent but the guys wanted to do some more digging, they searched the phone number for Tomorrow and came up with a Christ Rothwell.
Joseph remembers that Tyreme said Tomorrow's middle name is Christina but the guys still think there is something super weird going on. They check Facebook for Christ but there is no hits. They look into Letrease and realize that it is a real page however, there are no photos of Tomorrow and Letrease together. They search Christina Rothwell in Latrice's friends and they find a match.
They search for Tomorrow and also find her. They do some more digging and find a Shadeija.
They begin thinking Tyreme could be talking to Shadeija. Tomorrow is not the girl in the photo and the person catfishing Tyreme has some help.
The guys reach out to Shadeija, Letrease and Christina messages with Christina being the center of it all. They hope for Tyreme's sake, he at least knows some of these people.
Schulman and Joseph head over to Tyreme's to share the information they found. They take a seat and begin to walk him through all of the research. Tyreme doesn't recognize the Christ Rothwell character.
They tell Tyreme about Letrease's page and the fact that there is no photo of Letrease and Tomorrow. Tyreme learns that Christina Rothwell is friends with Letrease and so is Shadeija.
All of these individuals are connected to the same phone number and Tyreme has no idea who the other girls are.
The guys then show Tyreme the photo of Shadeija's ultrasound. They click on the ultrasound and they happen to be identical. Tyreme is baffled as to why someone would do this and the guys want to know if they are all in on it.
No one has returned a message and the guys believe it's because they were caught. They also show Tyreme the profile of Aryssa from Missouri, which means that Tomorrow is not who she says she is.
Tyreme seems crushed and lost. He says it's all hitting him at one time and he needs some answers.
They realize they need to make a move because these girls know that they are on their case. Schulman decides to call Tomorrow and reaches a voicemail. Schulman leaves a message and asks for a call back.
He proceeds to send a text and they wait for a reply. The guys leave Tyreme's place and he seems very let down by all of it.
During their ride home they receive a message from Christina. Christina tells them to come to Dothan and "they" will explain everything.
The guys call Tyreme and tell them exactly what they received. They leave to pick up Tyreme and head out to Dothan. Tyreme gave his daughter the bear instead of bringing it.
He says he received a call from Tomorrow at midnight but he did not answer. When they arrive Schulman has a message from Christina asking them to meet her team on a street at noon.
Without further delay, the guys hop in the SUV and head to the location. Tyreme doesn't want to hear anymore B.S.
They guys pull up and tell Tyreme that they are all in this together. They enter a porch and knock on the door. Someone answers the door and it happens to be Christina.
She says she is nervous and the guys reveal that they don't know what to expect. Christina says she has heard of Tyreme but she has never met him.
Christina says she had to respond because she feels responsible for some of it. Christina takes a minute to gather get someone and Letrease comes out.
The girls explained how the fake profile came about and Letrease says that she has asked him if he would date someone like her but he always said he wouldn't. Letrease says that Shadeija is Letrease's baby sister. Latrease says that Tyreme has spoken to her mom but her mother had no idea what was going on.
She admitted to the ultrasound being a lie. She says she tried to do it to push him away but he stayed.
Tyreme says he doesn't know what to say and has to leave the porch. Letrease tells Schulman that she is in love with Tyreme.
Tyreme is shaky but he is happy because he knows the truth now. He does feel bad about the things he said to Letrease but he says he needs a break. The guys ask Letrease if they could meet up some other time and she agreed.
The guys check in with Tyreme the next day and he says he will cherish the conversations they had.
They set out to meet up with Letrease who invites them in this time. Letrease wanted to see who her ex was talking to when she created the fake profile, however, he never accepted her friend request.
Letrease says that it really hurts that she had to go through everything because of her looks. Tyreme doesn't have a good reason for why Letrease would be fit for him. He says all of it is overwhelming and Letrease just keeps asking why she is not good enough for him.
She says her feelings are real and it was all about the picture. Joseph says that the whole package was not true and it goes both ways.
He says she can't trick someone into loving her back but she will meet someone who she can be herself around. The guys asks that Letrease some time so he can adjust.
They leave the room so that Tyreme and Letrease can talk alone. Letrease asks Tyreme why she can't be with him and he says she wants him to say it. Tyreme says he still wants to be Letrease's friend and she can feel free to contact him at any time. He says he will keep their conversations in his heart forever.
They eventually hug it out. Two months later Tyreme says he still talks to Letrease almost everyday.
He wants to keep the promise to be a friend to Letrease. The guys call Letrease who pretty much says the same thing Tyreme did.
Leave it up to MTV's Catfish to bring the unexpected out.
The skills of Schulman and Joseph are continuously put to the test but it's cases like this that show just how necessary they are for those who fall victim to catfishing.
Wanna read more on this? Check these out: 'Catfish' MTV Season 6 Episode 8 Recap: Ari and Lanum...Lanum is HOW OLD? (more); 'Catfish' MTV Season 6 Episode 9 Recap: Kailani & Sam (more); 'Catfish' MTV Season 6 Episode 7: Yasmine & Lewis, And Milo and Blue and Keerah (Watch) (more); 'Catfish' MTV Season 6 Episode 6 Recap: Mecca and Tanner, a Sith? (Watch) (more).
And here are some more related articles: 'Catfish' MTV Season 6 Episode 5: Marvin and Austin...And 3 Catfishes...And a Boyfriend (more); 'Catfish' MTV Season 6 Episode 4: Telizza, Shai, and An Abandoned Lot (Watch) (more); 'Catfish' MTV Season 6 Episode 3 Recap: Danny and Rosa, You'll Never Believe Who Rosa Is (more).
A few more: 'Catfish' MTV Season 6 Episode 2 Recap: Alante and Nevaeh (more); 'Catfish' MTV: 'Kayla & Courtney' Recap, The Craziest Catfish Episode to Air (more).